Home

Should the Electoral College be abolished

Abolish the electoral College Yes, because this country is a democracy and the popular vote should count not the electoral votes. Also this should not depend on the government, for the president is serving us, not the government Abolishing the Electoral College would get rid of this confusing process. There can be distinctive advantages to one party in a decade where three election cycles are possible. It also stops the distribution process where California gets 55 votes, but a state like Delaware only gets 3. Every vote would count equally instead Hillary Clinton's growing lead over Donald J. Trump is now over 1 million votes, making this the second time a president has been elected without a popular majority since 2000. That year, Akhil.. That is a laborious process and a constitutional amendment to abolish the Electoral College would require significant consensus—at least two-thirds affirmation from both the House and Senate, and..

Should the electoral college be abolished? Debate

14 Pros and Cons of Abolishing the Electoral College

  1. Getting rid of the Electoral College would be the same as turning the election over to those states with the highest populations. That would mean that unless you happened to live in one of those states, your vote wouldn't matter. Are you sure that you want to do that? After all, what's citizenship, if you don't have the power to vote
  2. ating electoral votes also point to potential benefits in terms of civic engagement and vote integrity. The following five reasons to abolish the Electoral College are offered by supporters of using a different approach to presidential elections. 1. Match Direct Elections at Local and State Leve
  3. The Electoral College can and should be abolished by a Constitutional Amendment. Unfortunately, that won't be easy because 38 states will have to agree, and some smaller states may want to preserve their disproportionate share of power

Should the Electoral College Be Abolished? - Room for

It's time to abolish the Electoral Colleg

Nevertheless, I doubt the wisdom of abolishing the Electoral College. There are, however, changes that should be made to limit the inroads the Electoral College can make on majority rule. First,.. National elections should be administered by the federal government. I repeat, the Electoral College should be abolished. LAWRENCE KING. Howland. NEWSLETTER. Today's breaking news and more in your.

Should the Electoral College be Abolished

  1. The Electoral College should be abolished. Pros Cons The Electoral College no longer works as it was intended by the Founding Fathers. The fact that it no longer serves this purpose suggests that it is no longer necessary. The Electoral College system results in unfair outcomes for voters..
  2. The Electoral College should be abolished is the topic of this debate. The Electoral College was created in September, 1787 after many arguments of how the president should be elected. Now with the Electoral College every four years, the states choose presidential electors (the same amount of their representatives for Congress)
  3. It is unlikely that the Electoral College will ever be abolished because the smaller states (which are many in number) would vote against its abolition
  4. The Electoral College is quite simply not fit for the times and should be abolished. Let me finish by quoting a tweet from democratic senator Ed Markey on December 15th, 'The Electoral College is an indefensible institution designed to rob voters of their power and it must be abolished.'. Display cover image courtesy of Wikipedia
  5. The Electoral College Should Not be Abolished. Opinion. A map of how the electoral college voted in the 2016 election. Though the system seems unfair, it gives a chance for citizens in less populated areas to have their voices heard. Photo Courtesy of Business Insider

Why the Electoral College Will Not be Abolished. Steve Chapman, a columnist at the Chicago Tribune, has an excellent short article on the electoral college this morning. It explains why the candidates spend a disproportionate amount of time in swing states. Probably most readers knew why, but he does a particularly nice job in a short space Should Electoral College Be Abolished Essay. 796 Words4 Pages. Electoral college has been with us since the birth of the constitution, and to this day we are still using this type of system to this day. The Electoral College is a system that the United States uses to elect our upcoming presidents and vice presidents The electoral college was designed to balance democracy and federalism. Does it still serve that purpose? In this episode of POLICYbrief, Tara Ross and John. Stanford sociology professor Douglas McAdam says the electoral college, which determined this election, is an outdated system The Electoral College should be abolished, due to third parties having no representation, the case of an electoral tie, and the violation of political equality. First, third party candidates are nowhere seen in electoral votes

According to critics, the Electoral College is a faulty system that should be abolished and replaced by direct election. Supporters of the Electoral College system make convincing arguments that it is the best system to decide the Presidential election in a complex society such as the United States No, the electoral college should be reformed - winners in each representative's district would receive one electoral vote for that district, and winners of the overall population in the state would receive two electoral votes representing the two Senators for the state. Reply Agree Disagree Link ••• Electoral College Should Be Abolished 1129 Words | 5 Pages. 2305 27 November 2017 Should we abolish the electoral college? In the debate about whether or not we should abolish the electoral college, my concern, as well as so many others, is not on the small/big states or Democrat/Republican states, it is about what the people want Should we abolish the Electoral College? December 01, 2016. Alex Keyssar of Harvard University and James Ceaser of the University of Virginia explore the history and purpose of the Electoral College. TRANSCRIPT. This transcript may not be in its final form, accuracy may vary, and it may be updated or revised in the future

Why We Should Abolish the Electoral College - The New York

Should the Electoral College be abolished? Although Hillary Clinton (D) won the popular vote in the 2016 presidential election by a margin of almost 2.9 million votes, Donald Trump (R) won the election since he won 77 more electoral votes. Specifically, this was made possible by Trump winning swing states like Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania The electoral college is an old method and it should be abolished. It is an outdated part of the election system and I think that to truly have a president voted in by the majority, the majority of the individual votes should be counted. — Neha Dubey, 1 B. Thesis statement---Nowadays, the Electoral College betrays American values of majority rule: a candidate can win the election without a majority of popular votes; some states are overrepresented; and a large number of citizens get left out, thus, the Electoral College should be abolished. II The Electoral College Should Be Abolished, Reformers Say. The way that the United States elects its president doesn't necessarily make a whole lot of sense. And according to people like Colorado.

Should the Electoral College Be Abolished? A new Gallup poll shows continued high support for having a national popular vote for the presidency, rather than the Electoral College. George C. Edwards, distinguished professor of political science at Texas A&M University in College Station, Texas, agreed, in an interview with The Christian Post Senator Barbara Boxer has proposed an amendment to abolish the Electoral College. There have actually been many, many attempts over the years, some of which have come very close to succeeding. Whether we should or should not abolish the electoral college has been on the minds of many people, especially since the election for the presidency in 2016. In this election, Donald Trump managed to win against Hillary Clinton with 302 electoral votes even though he lost the popular vote by 2.7 million votes The DBQ title Should The Electoral College Be Abolished is intended to teaching students to become better analytical thinkers. The target will be thoughtful answers from students. The DBW requires two to five class sessions to complete depending on student background knowledge with the DBQ process

Should the U.S. Keep the Electoral College? Online ..

The Electoral College: Top 3 Pros and Cons - ProCon

  1. Abolish the electoral College. Yes, because this country is a democracy and the popular vote should count not the electoral votes. Also this should not depend on the government, for the president is serving us, not the government
  2. Opinion: The electoral college should be abolished. One of the most pressing issues of our time and for generations to come is the system we use to elect the president of the United States. The electoral system currently employed in the U.S. is a disgrace to our democracy and the values that American citizens live by
  3. The Electoral College is a critical part of the concept of federalism, and fundamental to our system of government. Its origin dates back to the Constitutional Convention of 1787, and it was an.

Why We Should Never (Ever) Abolish The Electoral College

  1. ates, violates democratic principles, and is ultimately unfair. The Electoral College should be abolished to become an equal election
  2. Electoral College Should Be Abolished The Electoral College system was first established in the constitution by the Founding Fathers. The creation of Electoral College is to make sure every states is a viable participant in electing the president, in which giving the small population states a chance
  3. The Electoral College Should Be Abolished. With claims of voter fraud and a slew of lawsuits, the election of 2020 was one for the history books. As ballots were counted--and recounted--the election was decided by a slim margin of only a couple hundred thousand votes in a few key states. Yet, despite this close result and heavy.
  4. The United States should switch to direct popular vote and abolish the Electoral College, but it's not going to happen. Doing it would require a Constitutional amendment that would require ratification by legislatures in at least some of these mor..

The Electoral College Should Be Abolished. Many Americans are requesting that the Electoral College be abolished due to inconsistencies, for example: The Electoral College votes are not equally dispersed for each state, or someone could become President by winning only 21.8% of the popular vote, and the swing states vs the safe states which can favor one candidate over the The Electoral College Should be Abolished. Q&A with Esther Little Dove John. The Supreme Court has not reinforced our belief that the Electoral College should be a barrier to the inappropriate candidate. Therefore, should a similar situation arise, Quakers must know that they will likely not be backed up when their case goes to the nation. Should the Electoral College be abolished or modified? Introduction Almost everyone in America, thanks to the presidential election mess of 2000, knows that the Constitution provides that the president will be selected by an Electoral College, not by direct popular vote. Only 538 persons, representing the slates of electors chosen by voters in.

Petition · Abolish the Electoral College · ChangeShould the Electoral College Be Abolished? | Newsburglar

They should have the ability to make their vote directly count, which they can't do with the Electoral College deciding the vote on a state-by-state basis. Over time, the EC (Electoral College) has lost its original intent, said Andy Merritt, State High's AP Government and Comparative Government teacher Proposals to abolish the Electoral College, though frequently put forward, have failed largely because the alternatives to it appear more problematic than is the College itself. The fact that the Electoral College was originally designed to solve one set of problems but today serves to solve an entirely different set of problems is a tribute to. Any proposal to get rid of the electoral college is a non-starter, since the smaller states will never, never approve it, and there are more than enough of them to ensure defeat of the amendment. So it's pointless to argue about whether the electoral college should be abolished

But when Bush was named president after the 2000 election, some Americans began to wonder: should the Electoral College be abolished? PRO: The Electoral College is undemocratic and obsolete CMV: The electoral College should be abolished. [Election] I was having a discussion with a coworker who was a fan of the electoral college. His argument was that it gives the smaller states, such as Rhode Island, a voice in who becomes the next President The next step is on Monday, Dec. 19, when the Electoral College votes. Which raises the question: Should the Electoral College elect presidents, or should that be done directly by the voters A. This spring, numerous candidates for president expressed support for either abolishing or changing the Electoral College, which ultimately picks the U.S. president. The National Archives reports that over the past 200 years more than 700 proposals have been introduced in Congress to reform or eliminate the Electoral College - without any becoming law Prescott Valley, AZ Correspondent-The Electoral College should not be abolished. If it were, a few states, namely Blue ones would predominate in a presidential election and the rest of the country would suffer for lack of representation, and votes would be overshadowed and nullified. In the spirit of the Constitution, the winner of the Electoral

5 Reasons to Abolish the Electoral College - Electoral

Rural Americans would be serfs if we abolished the Electoral College If the National Popular Vote drive kills the Electoral College, rural and small town Americans who supply our food and energy. John G. Wells - October 28, 2011. If we abolish The Electoral College the election would be decided by Florida, the East Coast and the West Coast. Liberals would win every time with the big cities. This would take the vote away from the rest of America. Our founding fathers were able to set the voting up right Abolishing The Electoral College Would Be More Complicated Than It May Seem. Presidential candidate Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., at an organizing event in February. Warren says she wants to get.

Why the Electoral College Should be Abolishe

  1. Electoral College Debate Today, many people believe the Electoral College should be abolished and replaced with a national popular vote. Opponents of the system argue that the Electoral College is outdated and causes candidates to ignore voters from the vast majority of states
  2. Keep the electoral college. Abolish the permanent reapportionment act of 1929. THAT will bring the House back into balance. Instead of an artificial limit on House members from each state, scale the number of members by the population of the smallest state, or the average population of 3 to 5 of the smallest states
  3. Hoover Institute For Debate: Should the Electoral College Be Abolished? Published July 21, 2021 Is the Electoral College antidemocratic? The Founders rejected the direct election of the president in order to balance individual liberty against majority rule. In addition, the Electoral College enco..
  4. Why The Electoral College Should Be Abolished And Ever since its creation at the Constitutional Convention in 1787, the Electoral College has been the most widely debated aspect in the Constitution. Ther
  5. The Electoral College should not be abolished because of the way it keeps the government and elections organized. Although the Electoral College is an archaic form of election, that does not mean that it is insufficient and should be abolished. The Electoral College is a sure-fire way to guarantee the results of the election
jobsanger: Consensus Electoral College Map

Electoral College Debate: To Keep or Abolish? - Academy 4S

The electoral college is antiquated and needs to go. The GOP has won the popular vote only once in the last 30 years. Moving to a popular vote would ensure every single voter, in every single state, has an equal say in federal elections. As it stands today, republican voters in california or Illinois or new York are irrelevant Working with this service is a pleasure. Their Support is real people, and they are always friendly and supportive. I had Ap Essay Should The Electoral College Be Abolished a problem with my payment once, and it took them like 5 mins to solve it. Their writers are also pretty cool 10 Reasons Why We Should Abolish the Electoral College - Paste Top 10 Reasons It's Time to Abolish the Electoral College. This November was no doubt an exciting one. For what seemed like an eternity, multiple candidates battled for the title of American President, eac The five electoral failures throughout history where a candidate has lost the popular but won the presidency have gone to republicans. It happened in 1824, 1 876, 1888, 2000 and now, 2016. The electoral college often helps Republicans in close races. Abolishing is not in any way 'unfair,' nor does it give coastal states disproportionately. The outcome has prompted some to question whether the Electoral College —the body of officials that formally elects the nation's president every four years—is good for democracy, and even compelled outgoing California Sen. Barbara Boxer to file legislation to abolish the 229-year-old system

Yes, we should abolish the Electoral College. No, we should keep the Electoral College. The Electoral College gives a minority disproportionate influence. The Electoral College doesn't reflect the popular vote. The Electoral College disproportionately reflects demographic shifts in the U.S. The Electoral College ensures that all states are valued Should the Electoral College be abolished? Air Date: October 27, 2020 10:00 am. Listen 49:43. (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) Five times in U.S. history the presidential winner has lost the popular vote, including in the 2000 and 2016 elections. This has heightened calls to abolish what some say is an antiquated system of electors The question: has the Electoral College served the nation well or should the Electoral College be abolished and replaced with a system under which every vote counts the same? Joining us today, two guests: Jack Rakove is a professor of history and political science at Stanford University If the electoral college were abolished, the voices of citizens of the smaller less popular states would be abolished. The Electoral College embodies the concept of Sovereign States united under a.

10 Reasons Why We Should Abolish the Electoral College - Past

However, this is different in America, where something called the Electoral College is the deciding factor. In fact, the Electoral College is one of the most polarizing topics up for debate in the political world at the moment. The question surrounding the matter: Should it or should it not be abolished His recent book is Let the People Pick the President: the Case for Abolishing the Electoral College (St. Martin's Press, 2020). Trent England is the David and Ann Brown Distinguished Fellow at the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs The electoral college should be abolished. The Electoral College is an outdated system that stifles what the people truly want and doesn't encourage a high voter turnout. We need a change. We need to pass the National Popular Vote bill. When the Electoral College is explained, people usually say this type of election helps give both high.

Nov 29, 2016. Cazenovia College. 1387. The electoral college creates the possibility for the loser of the popular vote to win the electoral vote. In other words, a candidate can receive far more votes than their opponent, but with the complications of the electoral college can still lose the presidency. This was seen in the 2000 election, where. Other reasons people oppose abolishing the electoral college: It makes it more reliable to count votes, especially in a close election. If a president's win hinges on a 0.1% national popular vote advantage, that is an entire country to recount, whereas if the win is by 0.1% in Florida, the recount need only be isolated to that particular state Matthew J. Ryan Center: Should the Electoral College be Abolished? The Matthew J. Ryan Center for the Study of Free Institutions and the Public Good at Villanova University, a JMC partner program, will be hosting Akhil Reed Amar and JMC faculty partner Allen Guelzo for a debate on the electoral college.This will be the first of three debates at Villanova this year which comprise the Ryan. The electoral college was designed to balance democracy and federalism. Does it still serve that purpose? In this episode of POLICYbrief, Tara Ross and John Koza debate the merits and failings of the Electoral College. Should the U.S. keep the electoral system it has? Should the system be changed or abolished Watkins2 democracy but also Tara Ross, the author of an article explaining the strengths of the electoral college and why it should not be abolished. According to Tara Ross the founding generation did not intend to create a direct democracy. To the contrary, the Founders deliberately created a republic (Ross, Opposing Viewpoints in Context).Here Ross explains that again the founding fathers.

Hillary Clinton ‘proud’ to cast vote for Biden as elector

A presidential candidate must get at least 270 Electoral College votes to win the office. In recent years, state lawmakers have debated the continued use of the Electoral College. Should it be left intact or abolished? Improved or replaced? Opinions differ. We offer two views here Arguably, things like the Electoral College, gerrymandering, voter ID laws, etc., too often interfere with the will of the many.. On a post-election Bill Maher show, former U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder told Maher that the Electoral College needs to be abolished. Maher commented: That is some heavy lifting. Virtual Debate: Resolved: The Electoral College Should be Abolished Virtual Debate: Resolved: The Electoral College Should be Abolished Time: Thu Apr 1, 2021, 12:45 pm - 2:00 pm. Location: Virtual . Please join us for a virtual debate with Jesse Wegman, New York Times, and Trent England, Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs Amending the Constitution to abolish the Electoral College system in the U.S. requires support from two-thirds of both houses of Congress and three-quarters of the 50 states. Given the current polarization among partisans on the issue, there is little chance that such an amendment will happen anytime soon

A modest majority of Americans continue to favor changing the way presidents are elected, as they did in a January 2020 survey: 55% in the new poll say the system should be changed so that the winner of the popular vote nationwide wins the presidency, while 43% favor keeping the Electoral College system.The current balance of opinion is little changed over the last few years The Electoral College should be abolished. No: The constitutionally mandated Electoral College system provides a crucial check on what would otherwise be the unchecked will of the people. In structuring the Electoral College as they did, the Constitution's framers devised a way of representing the views of both the people who elect the. Both the opponents and proponents of the Electoral College should acknowledge this fact in the debate over whether it should be abolished. That would require them to think about politics as an activity instead of as a means to an end. Doing so illuminates the fact that the Electoral College is part of a complex arrangement of constitutional.

If the electoral college is not abolished, though, I think we badly need to ban faithless electors and require all states to use the winner-take-all (WTA) method. I can see how, in requiring candidates to compete in a wide variety of states, the electoral college does have some advantages For Debate: Should the Electoral College Be Abolished? As the 2020 presidential election approaches, the National Constitution Center in Philadelphia hosts a traveling debate on a question at the center of public discourse: is Electoral College is outdated or does it remain a vital aspect of our constitutional republic? Join James Ceaser.

Should The Electoral College Be AbolishedShould the Electoral College Be Abolished? - Room forElectoral College - HISTORY

The closest we came to abolishing the Electoral College was in 1969-1970, when the House of Representatives passed a constitutional amendment by an 82 percent vote. It had majority support in the Senate, but it was defeated by a Southern filibuster. CM Should the Electoral College be Abolished? Donald Trump won the 2016 presicential election by winning a majority of the Electoral College votes (306, 36 more than the 270 required to Win). even though he lost the popular vote to Hillary Clinton by nearly 3 million votes (roughly 63 mil ELECTORAL COLLEGE: The Electoral College is a body of electors established by the United States Constitution, which forms every four years for the sole purpose of electing the president and vice president of the United States. ABOLISHED: Formally put an end to. Burden of Proof: Shared PRO must prove why it should be abolished Nevertheless, the main concern lies upon the fact that whether the Electoral College should be abolished or not? This topic is considered to be one of the widely discussed topics, especially in the US context and in the recent times, it has also raised numerous debates that have cornered the political system to a large extent.. In the sense that the Electoral College didn't stop the steeel, then maybe it's broken. They're going to try to abolish it. I suggest having an alternate plan is a wise move Pearson, C. (2020, March-April). Winner-take-all ignores the will of too many voters: The Electoral College should follow the popular vote. State Legislature, 46(2), 29-33. Should we elect the president by popular vote? After hundreds of attempts to abolish Electoral College, opponents are promoting a plan to work around It